Split Versus Single Applications of Fungicides to Control Foliar Wheat Diseases

July 2018


Fungicides are useful tools in managing foliar diseases of wheat. Positive return on fungicide investment is dependent on several factors, including yield potential of the wheat crop and disease reaction of the variety being grown. In Oklahoma, a foliar fungicide application has typically consisted of a single application somewhere between full flag leaf emergence (Feekes growth stage 9) to full head emergence, but prior to flowering (Feekes growth stage 10.5). A single application of a fungicide in enough water to achieve thorough leaf coverage (usually 15 GPA) between these growth stages and before disease is severe can protect a wheat crop with a high yield potential from losses to foliar diseases.
During the last couple of years, an alternative approach to using a fungicide to facilitate wheat production has been proposed. This approach involves applying a lower rate of a fungicide in late winter or early spring when the first or second node is detectable (Feekes growth stages 6 or 7) followed by a second fungicide application at a much higher rate later in the season between flag leaf emergence and flowering. A split application strategy can be beneficial as recently reported in the popular press. It is, however, very important to observe some significant commonalities among these articles. In order for split applications of fungicides to be effective, a lower rate of fungicide is applied early in the season followed by a higher rate later in the season. So, for a fungicide such as Quilt, this would mean applying 7 oz/acre early, followed by 14 oz/acre later, so the maximum cumulative amount of fungicide indicated on the label for a season (20.5 fl oz/A/season) would be applied.
It is also important to consider what the term “early” means in the world of fungicide application. An “early” fungicide tank mixed with topdressing will be done earlier than most of the studies reported. Growth stages 6 and 7, which correspond to the first and second nodes being visible at the base of tillers, generally occur in mid-March. This would be later than when topdressing should be done, so an additional trip across the field will be needed to apply the fungicide at GS 6 or 7. Also consider that a fungicide application at full strength provides protection from foliar diseases for approximately two weeks followed by a third week of partial protection. Hence, an early, lower rate application in January will not protect for as long as a higher-rate application, and may not be present at sufficiently high levels to inhibit infections by tan spot or septoria in late February or March.

Figure 1. Tan spot on wheat – note underlying residue from which infective spores originated.

Figure 2. An infection of septoria on a wheat leaf. These infections also originate from residue as seen in Figure 1.

Another common element found among studies that have shown benefit to split fungicide applications is a low- or no-till production environment where tan spot and/or septoria leaf spots (Figures 1 and 2) are commonly encountered. Tan spot and septoria can be extremely detrimental to yield by killing leaves quickly and completely (especially on susceptible varieties in wet weather). Stripe rust (Figure 3) is another disease that can quickly and completely destroy leaves. Results from a trial in Louisiana in which split and single applications were used to control severe stripe rust have been published (Table 1). Note that the most important message from these data was to apply a fungicide rather than to split the application of a fungicide.

Figure 3. Stripe rust is an aggressive foliar disease that can drastically reduce yields in susceptible varieties if left unchecked. Photo courtesy of Cereal Disease Lab.

 

Table 1. Control of stripe rust of wheat in Louisiana and affect on yield (from Padgett & Purvis. 2007. Plant Disease Management Reports 1:CF009).    
†Fungicide applied on 13-Mar
‡Fungicide applied on 24-Feb
Fungicide (fl oz/A)Growth stageStripe rust
April 5, 2018
Stripe rust
April 19, 2018
Grain yield
% severity% severity% severitybu/ac
No Treatment9469772
Tilt @ 2.3 oz914991
Headline @ 6.2 oz985490
Quadris @ 6.2 oz924190
Quilt @ 14 oz9113102
Stratego @ 10 oz904694
Tilt @ 2 oz fb.
Quadris @ 6.2 oz
6 & 9244100
Tilt @ 2 oz fb.
Headline @ 6.2 oz
6 & 9240102
Tilt @ 1.1 oz fb.
Quilt @ 10 oz
6 &92293
LSD (P=0.05)8147

So, is there benefit to splitting the application for diseases such as leaf rust and powdery mildew in Oklahoma? As indicated in Table 2, the evidence is not as favorable as in some of the popular press articles. Examination of these data indicates that an early application of Quilt at growth stage 7 significantly reduced powdery mildew in the early season, but was not as effective in controlling leaf rust as a single later application at GS 10. Further, none of the treatments significantly increased yield over the non-treated check. Keep in mind that these yields were also greatly affected by heavy rain and lodging that was common in 2007. However, similar results were observed in 2006, an extremely dry year, and in 2008 which was an excellent year for wheat in Oklahoma (Table 3).

Table 2. Control of powdery mildew and leaf rust on winter wheat in Oklahoma using split and single applications of fungicide in 2007.    
†Fungicide applied on 19-Mar in 20 GPA water
‡Fungicide applied on 04-Apr in 20 GPA water
Fungicide (fl oz/A)Growth stagePowdery MildewLeaf rustGrain yield
April 5April 19
% severity% severity% severitybu/ac
No Treatment789811
Quilt @ 7 oz fb. 7oz7 & 10147314
Quilt @ 14 oz10784313
Tilt @ 4 oz10785612
Stratego @ 10 oz10656914
Headline @ 6.2 oz10714614
LSD (P=0.05)19154
Table 3. Control of powdery mildew and leaf rust on winter wheat in Oklahoma using split and single applications of fungicide in 2008.    
†Fungicide applied on 25-Mar in 20 GPA water
‡Fungicide applied on 07-Apr in 20 GPA water
Fungicide (fl oz/A)Growth stagePowdery MildewLeaf rustGrain yield
May 8May 12
% severity% severity% severitybu/ac
No Treatment467875
Quilt @ 7 oz fb. 7oz7 & 1040102
Quilt @ 14 oz1040105
Tilt @ 4 oz1031496
Stratego @ 10 oz10151389
Headline @ 6.2 oz10242195
LSD (P=0.05)15108

In summary, information available so far indicates that splitting a fungicide application may have the greatest benefit for wheat being produced in a low- or no-till system where a variety susceptible to tan spot and/or septoria has been planted. This is especially true in areas where spring wheat is grown as the overall season is much shorter than in regions where winter wheat is cultivated. With weather favorable for disease development in such a scenario, an early fungicide application may reduce early infection of lower leaves by inoculum coming from the residue. However, a second fungicide application at a higher rate also may be needed to continue disease protection later in the season. This approach may also be applicable to a disease such as stripe rust when “hot-spots” are found in a field in January or February. In contrast to this scenario, controlling powdery mildew and leaf rust may best be approached with a single application later in the season. These diseases usually do not kill leaves as quickly or effectively as tan spot, septoria, or stripe rust, and applying a single application of a fungicide before the disease becomes severe is a sound strategy.

 

Dr. Jeff Edwards
Small Grains Extension Specialist
Plant and Soil Sciences
Oklahoma State University

Dr. Bob Hunger
Retired Extension Wheat Pathologist
Department of Entomology and Plant Pathology
Oklahoma State University

DASNR Extension Research CASNR
OCES  Contact
OCES
139 Agricultural Hall
Oklahoma State University
Stillwater, OK 74078
OKLAHOMA STATE UNIVERSITY