Influence of Hybrids on Cold Soil Germination in Grain Sorghum

April 2019


Early season growth is one of the most critical aspects of grain sorghum production. Within 30 days following emergence, total grain numbers are being set and any stress or reduced growth will greatly inhibit yields. To minimize these risks and optimize early growth, sorghum must be planted in a timely manner and into favorable soil conditions. This typically entails good soil moisture with soil temperatures at or above 58 F. However, with potential damages and additional costs associated with sugarcane aphids (an emerging pest in the sorghum industry), growers have become interested in planting sorghum earlier as a tool for managing these pests. Earlier planting would allow the crop more time to mature unhindered by the pest as well as potentially reaching later reproductive stages prior to potential infestation, which will often result in less yield reduction (Table 1).

Table 1. Impact of sugarcane aphids on grain sorghum yield loss based on growth stage of infestation. 
Adapted from Gore, MSU.
Crop stage at 20%
infestation
Percent yield loss with
no applied control
Pre-boot81 to 100%
Boot52 to 69%
Panicle emergence0.67
Soft dough0.21
Hard dough<10%

While this may be an effective strategy, planting into cooler soils could result in delayed germination and emergence, as well as reduced early season vigor, lower early season root development and delayed maturity. These issues would negate the benefits of early planting by not allowing the crop to mature quicker. Many growers have looked toward hybrid selection as a way to mitigate the risks of planting into cool soils. Some hybrids have been marketed as having good cold/cool soil emergence; however, this testing is not universal and little direct comparison between hybrids has been conducted.

Cold Germination Tests
To determine the ability for hybrids to be planted into cooler soils, cold germination tests were conducted. Hybrids were germinated at the standard 60 F and 53 F (below the recommended temperature). Seeds were considered germinated if the coleoptile was longer than 1 inch, the typical requirement to emerge at standard planting depths. Counts were conducted at 10 days following placement into the germination chambers. Germination values at cooler conditions were subtracted from germination in standard conditions to determine the percent reduction in germination (Table 2).

Table 2. Percent reduction in germination associated with cooler conditions. Values were the difference of germination at 60 F and 53 F, where seed was considered germinated if coleoptile length exceeded 1 inch.      
<20% reduction in germination in cooler conditions20 to 35% reduction in germination in cooler conditions>35% reduction in germination in cooler conditions
DekalbDKS 33-07
DKS 29-07
DKS 37-07
DekalbDKS 47-07Pioneer84P72
Pioneer85Y34
85P44
Alta GrainAG 1201
Sharp BrothersSB 4117
Pioneer84P68
86P20
86G32
NuTechGS 725
GS 636
Gold SourceGS7016
AdvantaADV G2106
NuTechGS 693
GS 663
Richardson SeedRS 124
Sorghum PartnersSP 73B12
SP7715
AdvantaADV G3247
ADV G2275
Sharp BrothersSB 3217
Alta GrainAG 1203Gold SourceGS6717
GS7117
Dyna-GroM60GB31
M74GB17
Richardson SeedSwift
Sorghum PartnersSP 68M57

Summary
Several hybrids are currently available that will only experience minor reductions in germination/emergence when planted into soils with temperatures below the optimum 58 F. It should be noted that these reductions could still be up to 20 percent. Additionally, soil temperature is only the first factor to consider when deciding whether to plant early. While soil does not typically have major swings in temperatures, similar to air temperatures, prolonged cooler conditions following planting can negatively influence the crop. Hybrid selection does provide growers with options for planting early but critical and optimal soil temperature for planting have been established because it provides better conditions for the crop to germinate and emerge.

 

Josh Lofton
Cropping Systems Specialist

Anna Zander
Graduate Student

Chase Harris
Agricultural Technician

Related Categories

DASNR Extension Research CASNR
OCES  Contact
OCES
139 Agricultural Hall
Oklahoma State University
Stillwater, OK 74078
OKLAHOMA STATE UNIVERSITY