The Basics of Vermicomposting

February 2017


Introduction
This Fact Sheet is for people interested in making compost with worms – whether they intend to do it under the kitchen sink or on a two-acre worm farm.  Vermiculture (raising earthworms) and Vermicomposting (making compost with worms) have their own special vocabulary.  This Fact Sheet helps explain some of those words.  It also shows how vermicomposting is different from traditional, or microbial, composting. Some people will tell you vermicomposting is harder than traditional composting, but most will also agree the challenges of vermicomposting pays off with superior compost.  Vermicomposting is not the same as raising worms to sell as bait.  Composting worms are small and live in groups of several worms.  Composting worms are much easier to grow than baitworms, and can still be used for fishing.  It is a little harder to put a small composting worm on a hook, though.
The scientific name for the most commonly used composting worm is Eisenia fetida.  In everyday language, worms belonging to the species Eisenia fetida are called red wigglers.  Be careful, though—many other worm species are called red wigglers, and some of these, such as Lumbricus rubellus and Asian species in the Amynthas genus, are damaging invasive pests.  A more accurate name for Eisenia fetida is tiger worm or red tiger worm.  The name comes from the distinctive dark and light colored banding that is unique to Eisenia fetida.   For a more in depth look at the life and habits of composting worms, see OSU Factsheet, BAE-1529, “The Biology and Ecology of Composting Worms (Eisenia fetida).”    To identify tiger worms, and learn more about invasive worm species visit: http://www.nrri.umn.edu/worms/identification/index.html

Vermicomposting versus Microbial Composting
Vermicomposting is similar to traditional composting. Both use natural processes to stabilize organic matter (Figure 1).    Traditional composting relies on fungi and microorganisms to stabilize organic matter; therefore, it is sometimes called microbial composting. Worms do most of the composting in vermicomposting.  Both microbial and worm composting are aerobic processes – they require oxygen (O2) to function.  One advantage of vermicomposting is you do not need to aerate or turn a vermicompost pile.  The worms do the turning for you.   Excess energy is given off as heat in microbial composting (Figure 1).  In vermicomposting, most of this energy is tied up in worm biomass.  In fact, the last thing you want is a vermicompost pile to heat up.  Composting worms hate heat.  If they can, red wigglers will escape from hot compost piles.  If they cannot escape, they usually die.  Few things smell worse than dead tiger worms.

Figure 1. The difference between microbial composting and vermicomposting.

 

Types of Vermicomposting Systems
No matter how large or small, vermicomposting piles are contained in three basic types of systems: bins, beds and windrows.
Worm Bins are completely above ground, and they come in all shapes and sizes (Figures 2 and 3).  Small bins are relatively portable (Figure 4).   Being above ground makes it easy to remove worms and vermicompost from bins.  The downside of bins is they can change temperature rapidly.  You may need to insulate, cool or heat bins to keep the worms happy year round.
Worm beds are long troughs dug or placed into the soil (Figure 5).  Because soil temperature stays fairly constant, beds solve the problem of worms getting too hot or too cold. Beds put worms in their natural habitat – the earth.  The problem with worm beds is digging is required to remove worms or compost.
Worm Windrows are a compromise.  Windrows are long mounds sitting on top of the ground (Figure 6).  Being fairly large, windrows resist sudden changes in temperature.  And because they are above ground, windrows allow easy access for worm and compost removal.
The main disadvantage of windrows is their size.  You are not likely to set a worm windrow up in your kitchen.  If you want to get into worm farming in a big way though, a windrow may be the system for you.

Figure 2. Large vermicomposting bins (From www.sonomavalleywormfarm.wordpress.net).

 

Figure 3. Small vermicomposting bins placed directly beneath organic matter producers (From www.farmingintheforest.wordpress.net).

 

Figure 4. Vermicomposting bins for use in the home (from www.naturalsuburbia.com).

 

Figure 5. Vermicomposting swine manure in worm beds (from www.eXtension.org).

 

Figure 6. Preparing a vermicomposting windrow for winter (from www.redwormcomposting.com).

 

Primary versus Secondary Vermicomposting
Primary vermicomposting is feeding raw materials directly to the worms.  The stocking density (number of worms per surface area) of a primary system is high, because all of the nutrients contained in organic matter go towards raising worms.  On the down side, worms must be fed frequently and in small doses. Microorganisms will invade thick layers of raw organic matter before the worms can get to it and cause the layer to heat. This phenomenon is called autoheating.
In Secondary Vermicomposting, fungi and microorganisms compost raw material before it is fed to worms.  Autoheating does not occur in secondary vermicompost piles. The feeding rate (mass of organic matter added per surface) for secondary vermicompost systems is relatively high, because the organic matter has already been partially digested before the worms can eat it.  This means secondary bins are fed less frequently in thick layers.

Useful Products from Vermicomposting
The three products from vermicomposting are worms, vermicompost and vermicompost tea (Figure 7).

Figure 7. Inputs and products of vermicomposting.

The most obvious product of vermiculture is worms.  Red wigglers are prolific growers and multipliers.  Fed under optimum conditions, a group of composting worms doubles its mass every 60 days.  Another way of looking at this is that 10 percent of the worm biomass can be withdrawn from a bin every week and it will never run out of worms to sell.
Vermicompost is the stabilized solid material left after worms have eaten all the organic matter in a compost pile.  Vermicompost is often called castings.  Castings are worm feces, but it is really a misnomer.  Burrowing worms such as Nightcrawlers bring soil and feces to the top of their burrows and “cast” them out as a protective barrier around the worm hole.  Burrowing worms turn soil by bringing castings up to the surface. Composting worms do not have burrows, and they turn soil in exactly the opposite way.  Red wigglers eat organic matter at the soil surface and defecate approximately 6 inches below the surface.  It is almost impossible to pick out red wiggler feces in the midst of vermicompost.  Nevertheless, many producers separate fine material from vermicompost and sell it as “castings.” The remaining coarse material is marketed as mulch.
Vermicompost tea is the liquid that drips out of a worm bin, bed or windrow.  Tea is rich in nutrients.  It is called tea because of its reddish brown color.
Optimizing the Process to Target Desired Products
How you operate a vermicomposting bin depends on which of the three end products is most important.  If the main goal is to sell worms, it is best to keep the worms under controlled conditions, use primary vermicomposting, and feed a special “worm fattening” diet, such as the one given in Table 1. If the goal is to produce useful products from “waste,” then there are lots of options. The choice is to practice primary or secondary vermicomposting, and to use whichever style of container works best.

Table 1.  Typical Worm Fattening Diet. (from Vermiculture Canada, www.vermica.com)

5     parts chicken layer pellets or chick starter
2     parts wheat or rice bran
2     parts alfalfa pellets
1     part whole wheat flour
1     part agricultural lime
1     part powdered milk

Because worms must be kept moist, and organic matter shrinks during vermicomposting, a little tea will drip out of every vermicomposting system.  If the goal is to sell as much tea as possible, add more water than the minimum needed to maintain moisture.  Of course, the more water you add, the weaker the tea.
If collecting tea is a bigger problem than it is worth, cut back on the water, adding just enough to keep the pile moist.  Reducing water use may also increase the value of the vermicompost by concentrating nutrients with the solids.  Be careful, though.  Extra water may be needed to control the salts in some byproducts, such as urine soaked horse or cattle bedding.

Basic Environmental Requirements of Composting Worms
Temperature
Maximum growth of red wiggler occurs in the temperature range 65 F to 85 F (19 C to 29 C).  Composting worms can resist temperatures greater than 85 F for short periods of time, but die if exposed to high temperatures for very long.  They are more tolerant of temperatures below 65 F. Composting worms will survive unless the core temperature of their pile drops below freezing.  Cocoons (worm eggs) can survive for extended periods of cold and will hatch once warmth returns.
Moisture
Water is an absolute necessity for worm survival.  The optimum moisture content for growth is 70 percent to 85 percent.  This is a little wetter than microbial composting piles, which generally range from 50 percent to 60 percent moisture.  Red wigglers can survive in completely saturated bins for short periods, but will escape when oxygen starts to run out.
Carbon to Nitrogen (C:N) Ratio
Compost worms digest just about any type of organic matter, but they prefer higher amounts of carbon than is normal for microbial composting.  Organic wastes such as manure, kitchen wastes, coffee grounds, and freshly cut grass contain lots of Nitrogen (N).  You need to dilute these materials with byproducts containing high amounts of Carbon (C), such as straw, paper or fallen leaves.  The ratio of carbon to nitrogen in worm food is called the Carbon to Nitrogen Ratio (C:N).  Worms thrive when their food has C:N greater than 50. The main reason for this is microorganisms outcompete worms at lower C:N ratios.  At best, microorganisms take food from the worms’ mouth.  At worst, they cause the pile to heat, which kills the worms.
Acidity and Alkalinity
The measure of relative acidity or alkalinity of soil is pH.  Low pH levels (<7) indicate acid conditions; high pH (>7) indicates alkaline. Composting worms grow and reproduce best at neutral pH (pH = 7).  They will not survive in piles with pH lower than 5 or greater than 9.  Worms tolerate slightly higher pH ranges than other less desirable visitors to the compost pile, such as flies.  Lower pH also promotes the growth of fungus.  Worms will escape an area of low pH, but return to devour the fungi once pH returns to near neutral.

Summary
Vermicomposting is a fun and rewarding way to create high quality soil amendments on both a small and large scale.  Making compost from worms differs from microbial composting in that vermicomposting works best when initial C:N ratio is high, pile temperature is kept low and moisture content is high.  How your system operates depends on what end products is to be optimized.  If the goal is to raise worms to sell to others, raise the worms in beds of old compost and feed a special worm fattening diet.  If selling vermicompost, feed worms whatever organic matter is available. Feeding directly to the worms is called primary vermicomposting.  Letting the material go through a heating cycle in a microbial composting pile before feeding to the worms is called secondary vermicomposting. Whether practicing primary or secondary vermicomposting, composting worms prefer a feedstock with a slightly higher carbon content (C:N ~ 50) than traditional composting.
References
Kaplan, D.L, R. Hartenstein,  E.F. Neuhauser, and M.R. Malecki.  1980.  Physicochemical requirements in the environment of Eisenia foetida. Soil Biol. Biochem. 12:347-352.

 

Douglas W. Hamilton
Extension Waste Management Specialist

 

DASNR Extension Research CASNR
OCES  Contact
OCES
139 Agricultural Hall
Oklahoma State University
Stillwater, OK 74078
OKLAHOMA STATE UNIVERSITY